BOISE, Idaho – An alliance of pro-public education organizations and individuals has filed a lawsuit with the Idaho Supreme Court, challenging the state’s new voucher subsidy program established by House Bill 93.
The suit seeks a Writ of Prohibition against the law, which allows for a tax credit voucher for private education expenses. The Idaho Tax Commission, responsible for implementing the legislation, is named in the suit. Hawley Troxell, a Boise-based law firm, represents the coalition.
Daniel Mooney, president of the Committee to Protect and Preserve the Idaho Constitution, emphasized the importance of the Idaho Constitution’s Article IX, Section 1. “Interpreting these 14 words will be the task of our Supreme Court,” he said.
Shawn Tiegs, Superintendent of the Moscow School District, expressed concern over the bill’s impact. “Using taxpayer funds, House Bill 93 created a governmental system contrary to the constitution that is not general, uniform, thorough, or free,” said Tiegs.
Alexis Morgan, an Idaho parent, also voiced her support for public education. “I am standing here in defense of public education,” said Morgan.
The bill, signed by Gov. Brad Little, allows families to claim a refundable tax credit of up to $5,000 per eligible student, or $7,500 if the student has a disability, for education expenses outside the public school system. It faced opposition from more than 32,000 people who urged the governor to veto it.
Cindy Wilson, Idaho director of Mormon Women for Ethical Government, criticized the bill. “HB 93 is not only unconstitutional, it is unjust,” said Wilson. “It weakens our public schools, strips resources from the majority of Idaho children, and benefits only a few—at the expense of all.”
Paul Stark, executive director of the Idaho Education Association, highlighted the broader implications. “In the end, this isn’t just about schools,” he said. “It’s about the future we want for Idaho.”
For more details, see the full filing HERE. Video of the press conference is available HERE.
